In 2014, younger Jordan confessed his diet was taking control of his life. The blogger and vegetarian guru diagnosed herself with orthorexia nervosa, a new type of eating disorder where the obsession with healthy eating intensifies cutting whole food groups and work days around meals. Those suffering from the condition can refuse food that is not prepared, even if it is prepared for their loved ones. Some extreme cases crescendo to malnutrition.
 |
| click to enlarge |
The media coverage test younger confessional might suggest orthorexia is a well-established disease. It is not. While orthorexia nervosa captivates public awareness is only just permeating scientific consciousness and is not officially recognized by the medical community. Research is disjointed, and scientists do not agree on a definition or criteria for diagnosing it. Specialists recognize eating disorders, and the National Association of Eating Disorders has a website on the subject, but at this point no one can be officially diagnosed with orthorexia. Instead, people can diagnose themselves after referred by a doctor, or just learn about it through cultural osmosis.
Jordan Younger Vegan Rubio
For much of the medical community, orthorexia is a mere whim of alternative medicine flavored anorexia, bulimia, or obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). However, a small contingent of researchers see orthorexia as an eating disorder in its own right, the need for research and selective treatment, and want to establish a true diagnosis. They see potential ortoréxicos as a neglected group that falls through the cracks in the system of mental health care because they do not fit neatly into a box.
In a slow-motion battle takes through studies, reviews, and letters, they are trying to improve diagnostic criteria and definition of orthorexia. These researchers are concerned that if they do not, or orthorexia become a way of pathologizing healthy eating or simply fade into memory, a disease fashionable fad diets.
Steven Bratman used to believe food was medicine. It is believed that the right diet could cure most ailments, but so hard, scientific research began to refute his theories, he became disillusioned. Eventually, he abandoned his favor ideas supported by the science.
It was a practicing alternative medicine doctor when originally coined the term "orthorexia" in an essay in the Journal nonacademic Yoga published in 1997. It describes patterns of behavior that has been observed over the years, including itself, where healthy food became obsessive behavior and a fixation on the "purity of the extreme diet," or what he calls "spirituality kitchen," begins "to cancel other sources of meaning." he wrote on the subject for several years, he lectured and conducted interviews with the media, but has never worked as a research topic.
In 2004, a team of Italian researchers found the writings of orthorexia Bratman and began studying the disease in Italy. In one of the trials Bratman, posed 10 questions designed to help the reader to think in eating habits. The Italian group took six of the questions Bratman, added nine of his, and said it is a diagnostic tool. They called the ORTHO-15.
Bratman says the original questionnaire was never designed to be useful in diagnostic or research. The Italian researchers did not respond to the request by the Daily Dot for comment.
"His view was that it was a condition to believe in a non-standard diet" as vegan or gluten-free diets, he said. Although many people follow these diets, they all become orthorexic according to ORTO-15, Bratman said. With this tool, the proportion of people suffering from orthorexia ranges from 7 percent of the general population in Italy to a whopping 86 percent in ashtanga yoga practitioners in Spain.
"The most basic way to conceptualize orthorexia is a hybrid between an eating disorder and OCD." Bratman those high numbers attributed to the ORTO-15 and fixing its derivatives' in eating behaviors, concerns about nutrition, purity and preparation.
The ritual nature of healthy behaviors and improves healing promises of these diets, Bratman said. But while health and extreme claims that some diets make unrealistic, that does not mean that the signing of these disease, Bratman said.
"If a person thinks veganism protect them from heart disease, and you think they're crazy, that's just a disagreement," Bratman said. "You should not pathologizing a disagreement."
Bratman not realized its diagnostic questionnaire had not become the ORTO-15 and "proof of orthorexia Bratman," until 2014, after numerous studies using questionnaires were published.
Most of the research came from small magazines, sometimes not English in Europe, Australia and South America, unnoticed by the American scientific community. According to Bratman, many researchers were in the "conventional side of a culture war," the creation of a disease taking diet theories that are not supported by mainstream science.
"They had no insider knowledge about what it feels like to believe in alternative health," Bratman said. But he did. That was when Bratman started to correct errors he perceived in the investigation.
Around 2012, Thomas Dunn, a researcher of neuropsychology at the University of Northern Colorado, was found in the center of the debate on orthorexia. After stagnating in his research, he turned to the neuropsychological research in hospitals. There, a orthorexic patient who was the subject of one of the few case studies of America in the disorder was found.
The patient initially started your diet to relieve constipation, but over time, their concerns was oriented toward the purity of their food, and he began to restrict his diet until he was hospitalized for malnutrition.
"I was really stunned by it. I felt I knew the people who had the kind of condition. That was causing problems for people clearly, but it seemed that the US was not aware of it," says Dunn.
 |
GIF by Max Fleishman
|
Dunn says he was initially on the periphery of the box, but when the primary care physician became too busy to address critical issues and study, Dunn took over. He and his colleagues diagnosed the patient with orthorexia despite the absence of the disease from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM), the manual of diseases and disorders of the mind that social workers use to diagnose patients.
Bratman, who was not involved in the case study, said Dunn and his colleagues had a difficult time getting the article through the peer review process. anonymous experts to evaluate the scientific rigor of the article questioned the validity of the diagnosis. Although it was not the first case of orthorexia, which were not yet convinced. Some patients only had anorexia nervosa, obsessive compulsive disorder, or both reviewers suggested.
Both Bratman and Dunn confess that orthorexia has in common with other recognized eating disorders. Because American culture tends to equate health with thinness, orthorexia often mimics anorexia nervosa, while rituals and moralizing preparations for food harkens to the obsessions of OCD: Cutting food a demanding way to optimize their health benefits does not seem very different to wash one's hands and again to avoid contamination. These traits shared leading some experts to believe that orthorexia is not a disorder in its own right.
Tom Corboy, a therapist and executive director of the Center for Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder Los Angeles, believes that orthorexia is really TOC-with elements of an eating disorder.
"The most basic way to conceptualize orthorexia is a hybrid between an eating disorder and OCD," says Corboy. "It is certainly disordered eating, but on another level, it is important to note that the focus of obsession is not the weight or appearance, but, for lack of a better term, a fear of contamination."
Corboy said that, unlike mental health generalists and specialists in eating disorders, OCD specialists in the US They have been aware of for some time orthorexia. He said eating disorders centers often refer patients to his clinic with orthorexia.
His group uses cognitive behavioral therapy, an approach where patients learn to critically evaluate their obsessive thinking and relearn their relationship with the object of his obsession. For a patient with orthorexia, using this approach to help patients to unlearn their superstitions to food, while also gradually exposing them to food previously off limits. Corboy said this approach could work regardless of orthorexia is classified as an eating disorder or as a branch of OCD.
"Personally, I do not care if it is considered an eating disorder or OCD. Let's do what works when it comes to treatment," he said.
That's assuming, of course, orthorexia gets into the DSM at all.
Dunn and Bratman recently published a document that defines and offering new diagnostic criteria for orthorexia. The article, published in the journal eating behaviors, refers to the difference between a pattern of eating and the way such patterns dominate the life of a true orthorexic.
They believe that current diagnostic tools to orthorexia focus too much on the diet itself, and not enough on stopping the diet can cause in the lives of some people. There are many people who strive to eat healthier, and some even go to extremes to do so, but most can be rolled on and still enjoy things like Thanksgiving dinner with family or a night out with friends. Such activities can cause extreme distress in a person with orthorexia.
"In the DSM-V, 75 percent of those disorders saying that cause a problem with work, school or social functioning, or are so afflicted so raise your hand and say, 'I need help'" Dunn said. "It's crossing the line if you are malnourished, if the job says you can not take a lunch 90 minutes."
But diet is still important, as a risk factor
". An eating disorder can certainly manifest as an unhealthy fixation on eating only" healthy "but that alone does not necessarily constitute a clinical diagnosis" To explain what he meant, Bratman drew a parallel with the genre: Being a woman it is a risk factor for osteoporosis. But being a woman is not a symptom of the disease. Subscribing to a restrictive diet in particular, such as veganism is simply a risk factor. Some vegans develop orthorexia, but the vast majority will not.
Dunn and Bratman expect to refine the diagnostic criteria in future documents. They plan to raise several questions from more than 100 people suspected of having orthorexia but whose official diagnosis, if any, may be something else. Then, they will gradually reduce based on the questionnaire response. For example, if a question seems to resonate with the group and talk about their experience with orthorexia, then it is likely to stay in the final questionnaire. Bratman said this is the most common way to develop diagnostic criteria.
Even if developing a solid questionnaire, Dunn and Bratman have an uphill battle to convince the scientific community that orthorexia should join the 300 diseases currently listed in the DSM-V. The field of psychology is often at odds over whether to keep adding categories and subcategories for diagnostic volume.
Russell Marx, scientific director of the National Eating Disorders Association, sees orthorexia as it deserves its own category.
"The behavior has used the term" orthorexia "to describe are related to the temperament and personality of an individual. Many people with eating disorders, especially anorexia nervosa, tend to exhibit traits such as perfectionism, avoidance of damage , negative emotionality and rigidity, "Marx said by email.
"These personality traits often persist even in recovery. Therefore undoubtedly an eating disorder can manifest as an unhealthy attachment to eat only food" healthy "
but that alone does not necessarily constitute a clinical diagnosis. "
Corboy see otherwise.
"I'd say five years ago, people who eat in treatment of disorders were literally disappeared [orthorexia] completely," Corboy said. "They just prefer to conceptualize such as anorexia."
People with orthorexia are different because of their fixation is in the purity of food and health, not body image or thinness. It may seem like splitting hairs, but the recognition of these subtle distinctions in some official way through the DSM is important for care.
"From a clinical perspective, the presence of a diagnosis in the DSM is primarily beneficial because it gives legitimacy to something that we see on a regular basis," Corboy said.
He added that the official recognition of the disease increases the likelihood insurance companies to reimburse patients for treatment. It also makes it easier research; funding agencies are keener research into a disease that the medical community agrees that actually exists.
These are the factors fueling and Dunn Bratman search to define and get orthorexia in the DSM. Opponents can not see the point of definition of a disease that is, in their eyes, not significantly different from one of hundreds of people currently listed in DSM-V. However, the definition of orthorexia decisions in real time, which could shed light on the unhealthy behavior disguised as healthy.